Motor Trend Deep Dish Rubber Floor Mats vs Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor Mats
Head-to-head spec comparison to help you pick the right floor mat for your needs.
Motor Trend
$28
Smartliner
$80
Spec-by-Spec Comparison
| Spec | ||
|---|---|---|
| Material | Rubber | TPE |
| Fit Type | Universal Trim-to-Fit | Custom Fit |
| Coverage | Full Set (Front + Rear) | Full Set (Front + Rear) |
| Lip Height | 1 in | 1.5 in |
| Thickness | 4 mm | 4.5 mm |
| Anti-Slip Backing | Yes | Yes |
| Odor-Free | No | Yes |
| Trim-to-Fit | Yes | No |
| Weight | 5.9 lbs | 7.5 lbs |
| Warranty | 1 years | 1 years |
| Price | $28 | $80 |
| Rating | 7.2/10 | 7.9/10 |
| Check Price on Amazon | Check Price on Amazon |
Pros & Cons
Motor Trend Deep Dish Rubber Floor Mats
Pros
- Classic deep dish design holds a generous amount of liquid
- Cheapest full-set option in the Motor Trend lineup
- Flexible rubber stays pliable in cold weather
- Simple to hose clean in under a minute
Cons
- Thinnest rubber in the Motor Trend range — feels less premium
- Anti-slip backing is adequate but not the strongest
- Trim lines are slightly harder to follow than newer models
Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor Mats
Pros
- Solid custom-fit TPE at an approachable mid-range price
- Raised lip walls keep liquids contained across the full mat
- Non-toxic, BPA-free material is family-safe
- Available for many 3-row SUVs with rear coverage options
- Clean matte finish resists fingerprints and dirt
Cons
- Fit precision is good but not quite up to WeatherTech standards
- Some users report minor curling at edges in extreme heat
- Customer support can be slow to respond
Our Verdicts
Motor Trend Deep Dish Rubber Floor Mats
The Motor Trend Deep Dish is the no-frills budget pick for drivers who just need basic all-weather protection. It won't win any style points, but it catches mud and slush at a price that's almost disposable.
Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor Mats
Smartliner occupies a comfortable middle ground — better fitment than budget brands, at a price well below the premium tier. It's especially strong for SUV and truck owners who need 3-row coverage without breaking the bank.
More Comparisons
Motor Trend Deep Dish Rubber Floor Mats vs Motor Trend FlexTough Contour Liners Deep Dish Floor MatsMotor Trend FlexTough Contour Liners Deep Dish Floor Mats vs Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor MatsMotor Trend Deep Dish Rubber Floor Mats vs Motor Trend FlexTough Plus Heavy Duty Rubber Floor MatsMotor Trend FlexTough Plus Heavy Duty Rubber Floor Mats vs Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor MatsMotor Trend Deep Dish Rubber Floor Mats vs WeatherTech FloorLiner Custom Fit Floor MatsSmartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor Mats vs WeatherTech FloorLiner Custom Fit Floor Mats3D MAXpider Kagu All-Weather Floor Mats vs Motor Trend Deep Dish Rubber Floor Mats3D MAXpider Kagu All-Weather Floor Mats vs Smartliner Custom Fit All-Weather Floor Mats